Comments on: Definitive Guide to the Rule of Thirds http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/ Mon, 30 Aug 2010 21:50:37 +0200 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.6 hourly 1 By: throughHislens | sean http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-5051 throughHislens | sean Sun, 04 Oct 2009 04:27:36 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-5051 Also can be linked with the golden ration/golden rectangle other relating posts: http://aphotocontributor.typepad.com/aphotocontributor/2008/10/the-golden-ratio.html Also can be linked with the golden ration/golden rectangle

other relating posts: http://aphotocontributor.typepad.com/aphotocontributor/2008/10/the-golden-ratio.html

]]> By: JCdeR http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-4371 JCdeR Mon, 07 Sep 2009 13:13:12 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-4371 ... nice and informative site by the way … nice and informative site by the way

]]> By: JCdeR http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-4370 JCdeR Mon, 07 Sep 2009 13:11:27 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-4370 Perhaps time to try something new, disregard any rules and just go for photogrpahy, ruels tend to create levels of perfection, and perfection is boring..... try different things, try new things Perhaps time to try something new, disregard any rules and just go for photogrpahy, ruels tend to create levels of perfection, and perfection is boring….. try different things, try new things

]]> By: Candy Camarena-Dexter http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-4266 Candy Camarena-Dexter Mon, 31 Aug 2009 04:32:59 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-4266 thank you Mark and Steve for your awesome comments. I am learning photography. I love to take pictures, mostly landscapes. I love old barn, wildlife and the country, nature in all's it's beauty. I have a wonderful husband who takes me down different back roads to shoot old barns and we see alot of wildlife. My wildlife shot never turn out to well because i usually have to zoom in for them and it blurs them. I will try both of your suggestions. Thank you again. thank you Mark and Steve for your awesome comments. I am learning photography. I love to take pictures, mostly landscapes. I love old barn, wildlife and the country, nature in all’s it’s beauty. I have a wonderful husband who takes me down different back roads to shoot old barns and we see alot of wildlife. My wildlife shot never turn out to well because i usually have to zoom in for them and it blurs them. I will try both of your suggestions. Thank you again.

]]> By: steve http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-4202 steve Thu, 27 Aug 2009 04:10:36 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-4202 The rule of thirds is pretty simple, hard to think of anything more to make it definitive :) There are time where I find variations of the rule seem to work well: using 1/6 or cropping off 1/3. For example...take a standard aspect ratio landscape photo with the horizon line across the middle and take the same shot with it across the upper or lower third and the one with the horizon in the middle usually doesn't look quite right...but..if you take the one with it across a third and then crop away a third of the shot (but not the width) so that the horizon is back across the middle it now seems to work. Similarly, a nice landscape shot often looks nice with a foreground object 1/3 in from one side (a tree for example). But try with a tree 1/3 in each side and it doesn't work as well...but with a tree 1/6 in from each side seems to work. Obviously the subject you are shooting effects how well any photo "works" and also a good shot can often be subjective but for me the rule of thirds works well as a starting shot for the types of photos I take (mostly landscape/wide shots...not action of people) and cropping along a third and framing symetrically along 1/6 often gives me pleasing compositions. Experiment and find what works for you. A collection of "rule of half" or "rule of quarter" shots printed square might make a great collection when viewed together. Rule of Thirds is more what you'd call a guideline :) The rule of thirds is pretty simple, hard to think of anything more to make it definitive :) There are time where I find variations of the rule seem to work well: using 1/6 or cropping off 1/3.

For example…take a standard aspect ratio landscape photo with the horizon line across the middle and take the same shot with it across the upper or lower third and the one with the horizon in the middle usually doesn’t look quite right…but..if you take the one with it across a third and then crop away a third of the shot (but not the width) so that the horizon is back across the middle it now seems to work.

Similarly, a nice landscape shot often looks nice with a foreground object 1/3 in from one side (a tree for example). But try with a tree 1/3 in each side and it doesn’t work as well…but with a tree 1/6 in from each side seems to work.

Obviously the subject you are shooting effects how well any photo “works” and also a good shot can often be subjective but for me the rule of thirds works well as a starting shot for the types of photos I take (mostly landscape/wide shots…not action of people) and cropping along a third and framing symetrically along 1/6 often gives me pleasing compositions.

Experiment and find what works for you. A collection of “rule of half” or “rule of quarter” shots printed square might make a great collection when viewed together.

Rule of Thirds is more what you’d call a guideline :)

]]> By: Mark Evans http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-3962 Mark Evans Mon, 10 Aug 2009 19:24:56 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-3962 Hi, Chris cheers for your input, anything that you could add to this would be great! And of course if anyone else has got any more info to add to this post to make it more 'definitive' then please feel free to post here. cheers Hi, Chris cheers for your input, anything that you could add to this would be great! And of course if anyone else has got any more info to add to this post to make it more ‘definitive’ then please feel free to post here. cheers

]]> By: Chrisdavid42 http://www.smashandpeas.com/definitive-guide-to-the-rule-of-thirds/#comment-3960 Chrisdavid42 Mon, 10 Aug 2009 17:33:03 +0000 http://www.smashandpeas.com/?p=2299#comment-3960 Sorry to be negative, but more an intro to the rule, than a 'definitive' guide. Sorry to be negative, but more an intro to the rule, than a ‘definitive’ guide.

]]>